Canning Tomatoes Safely
Tomatoes sit on the border between high and low acid, so safe canning means added acid, tested recipes and attention to variety, ripeness and processing method.
Few preserving projects are as rewarding as a pantry shelf of home-canned tomatoes. Ripe tomatoes from a farm stand or a garden, turned into whole jars, crushed tomatoes, juice or sauce, bring summer into the middle of winter. They are also one of the most common sources of canning mistakes, because tomatoes are not as simple as they seem.
Tomatoes sit near the boundary between high-acid and low-acid foods. Depending on variety, ripeness and growing conditions, their acidity can vary, and that variation matters for safety. The standard guidance from home-preservation research is to add acid to every jar, in the form of bottled lemon juice or citric acid in the amounts a tested recipe specifies, and to follow processing methods exactly. The folks at FARM.FM food like to say that a tomato is a fruit that vegetables are jealous of, but for canning purposes, treat it carefully.
Why acid is added
Safe water bath canning depends on enough acidity to prevent growth of botulism-causing bacteria. Because tomato acidity can vary, tested recipes add a measured amount of acid to each jar for a margin of safety. Use bottled lemon juice or citric acid, since fresh lemons vary in acidity, and measure exactly as the tested recipe states. Do not skip the acid because you dislike the flavor; the taste is usually mild once cooked, and sugar can soften it if the recipe allows. Do not add acid by guesswork.
Choose good tomatoes
Quality fruit makes safer, better jars.
- Use ripe, firm tomatoes without blemishes, cracks or mold.
- Avoid overripe, soft or damaged fruit, and never use tomatoes from dead or frost-killed vines, since they may have lower acidity.
- Paste varieties give thicker sauces; slicers give juicier results.
- Process fruit promptly after picking or buying; see local tomatoes: heirloom vs hybrid.
- Buying bulk "seconds" works well if the fruit is sound; see buying produce in bulk for canning and freezing.
Which style to can
| Style | Notes |
|---|---|
| Whole or halved, packed in water or juice | Needs acid and a tested process |
| Crushed tomatoes | Good for sauces and soups |
| Tomato juice | Heated before filling per recipe |
| Plain tomato sauce | Cooks down; thickness affects tested time |
| Salsa | Use tested salsa recipes only; do not alter vegetable ratios |
Adding low-acid ingredients such as onions, peppers, garlic, mushrooms or meat changes the safety of a sauce. For these mixtures, either use a tested recipe that includes them, can the plain tomatoes and add other ingredients when you cook, or freeze the finished sauce. A tested recipe from the National Center for Home Food Preservation or your extension service is the right starting point.
Basic steps
Follow a current tested recipe for details. The general path:
- Wash tomatoes, then dip in boiling water briefly and cool to loosen skins.
- Peel, core and cut as the recipe directs.
- Add measured acid to each clean jar before filling.
- Fill with hot tomatoes or juice to the headspace the recipe lists, remove bubbles, and wipe rims.
- Apply lids and bands fingertip tight.
- Process in a boiling water canner, or a pressure canner if the recipe is tested for it, for the time given for your jar size, style and altitude.
- Cool undisturbed, check seals, remove bands, label and store.
Review water bath canning for beginners for equipment and technique.
Avoid these mistakes
- Skipping added acid
- Using untested or older family recipes
- Making sauce thicker than the tested recipe allows
- Adding extra peppers, onions or garlic to a tested recipe
- Ignoring altitude adjustments
- Reusing flat lids
- Using tomatoes from diseased or frost-damaged plants
Storing and using
Keep sealed jars in a cool, dark place without bands. Check before opening for bulging lids, leaks or off smells, and discard any jar that looks or smells wrong without tasting. Use within a year or so for quality. Once opened, refrigerate and use promptly. If you have separated liquid in the jar, that is usually harmless, but discard jars with spoilage signs. See home food preservation 101 and the CDC botulism pages for the risks.
A worked example: a Saturday of crushed tomatoes
You buy a case of ripe paste tomatoes from a farm stand and find a tested crushed-tomato recipe. You confirm your altitude and gather bottled lemon juice, jars, new lids and your canner. You blanch, peel and core the tomatoes, add the measured acid to each hot jar, fill with tomatoes, remove bubbles, wipe rims and process for the time the tested recipe lists for your jar size and altitude. After cooling overnight, every lid is sealed and concave. You label them and store them in a cupboard. In January you open one, add garlic and onion at that time, and simmer a sauce, which is how to keep added low-acid ingredients out of the jar.
When to freeze instead
If you lack time, equipment or a tested recipe, freezing is a simple option. Whole or chopped tomatoes freeze well for cooking uses; see freezing local produce at peak season. Roasted tomato sauce also freezes beautifully.
Planning a tomato canning day
Tomatoes ripen all at once, so plan ahead. Decide which styles you want, such as crushed tomatoes for sauces and whole tomatoes for stews, and gather jars, lids and acid before the fruit arrives. Work in batches that fit your canner, keep extra tomatoes cool and shaded, and avoid leaving cut fruit sitting out. Clean as you go, because tomato juice splatters everywhere and slippery floors are a real hazard.
A written checklist helps: tested recipe printed and within reach, altitude noted, jars washed and heated, lids ready, timer set, labels and marker nearby. If you are using a mix of tomato varieties, the added acid still applies to every jar. Many families can with a friend or two, since peeling and coring is the slow part. Keep notes on yield, because the number of jars you get from a bushel varies with the variety and how much juice you drain off. Over a few seasons those notes become your own guide to how much fruit to buy.
Frequently asked questions
Do I really need to add lemon juice or citric acid?
Yes. Tested recipes call for added acid because tomato acidity varies, and the measured addition provides a safety margin. Use bottled lemon juice or citric acid.
Can I can tomato sauce with onions and peppers?
Only from a tested recipe designed for that mix. Otherwise can plain tomatoes and add other ingredients when cooking, or freeze the sauce.
Is it safe to can heirloom tomatoes?
Yes, with the same tested recipe and added acid. Heirlooms vary in acidity and texture, which is another reason not to skip the acid.
Can I use a pressure canner for tomatoes?
Some tested recipes allow it, but follow the specific recipe. Do not substitute methods or times from different sources.