How to Compare Local Honeys Side by Side
A simple, fair side-by-side tasting reveals real differences between local honeys, as long as you control the setup, taste in a sensible order and record what you notice.
To compare local honeys side by side, set out small, equal portions of each honey on clean spoons or small plates, taste from lightest to darkest, and note color, aroma, texture, sweetness, acidity and aftertaste for each. Use water and plain crackers or bread to reset your palate, and keep notes. A few simple controls make the comparison fair and the differences easy to hear.
You do not need special equipment or training. What you need is a small group of honeys, an hour and some attention. This guide gives a step-by-step setup, a scoring sheet idea and a short list of things to look for.
Why bother comparing
Local honeys differ by floral source, season, region and handling. Tasting them side by side teaches you what you prefer and helps you pick honeys for different uses. It also helps you spot oddities, such as a honey that smells burnt from overheating or a jar that tastes thin and flat. Comparing also builds a better relationship with beekeepers because your questions become more specific. See why local honey tastes different from store-bought and a beginner's palate guide.
Set up the tasting
- Choose three to six honeys. More than six tires the palate. Include a range of colors if you can.
- Note the facts for each. Producer, location, harvest date, floral source if known and whether raw or strained.
- Pour equal portions. About a teaspoon each, on clean spoons or in small cups. Label with a code, or hide labels for a blind tasting.
- Use neutral room conditions. Room temperature honey, no strong scents from candles or cooking.
- Provide palate cleansers. Plain water, unsalted crackers or plain bread, sliced green apple.
- Prepare a notes sheet. One row per honey.
If honey is crystallized, warm it gently first or taste it as is and note the texture; see crystallized local honey.
Taste in a sensible order
Start with the lightest and mildest and finish with the darkest and strongest, because strong flavors can overpower delicate ones. If you include a smoky or very intense honey, put it last. Take a sip of water between honeys.
What to look for
| Aspect | What to notice |
|---|---|
| Color | From water white to very dark; clarity or cloudiness |
| Aroma | Floral, fruity, woody, herbal, caramel, earthy |
| Texture | Runny, thick, grainy, creamy |
| Sweetness | Delicate, rounded, intense |
| Acidity | Bright, tangy, flat |
| Flavor | Notes you can name: citrus, berry, spice, molasses |
| Finish | Short, long, lingering, bitter, clean |
For vocabulary see tasting notes for local honeys, local honey aroma and the flavor wheel. Smell first, with the honey held under your nose, then taste a small amount and let it melt on your tongue.
Keep a simple score
Rate each honey from one to five on a few things you care about, such as aroma, flavor and overall enjoyment. Add a line of notes and a "best use" suggestion. Do not worry about being "right." Preference is personal. If you compare with friends, discuss afterward, because people notice different things.
Controls that make it fair
- Same portion size for each honey.
- Same temperature. Warm honeys smell stronger.
- Same tasting utensil type.
- Blind labels if you want to avoid bias from price or packaging.
- Same time of day. Taste when you are not hungry or tired.
- No flavored beverages that dull your palate.
Ask the beekeeper what you are tasting
Armed with notes, ask producers about harvest timing, floral source and handling. A honey you find unusually dark may be late-season. One that tastes slightly burnt could have been overheated. The best questions to ask a local beekeeper page has more. If you are choosing among sellers, also consider how to verify local claims.
The National Honey Board and UC Davis Honey and Pollination Center publish resources on honey varieties and sensory evaluation, which are good references for vocabulary.
Beekeepers will tell you that honey tasting is the only tasting where a spoon is both the glass and the evidence, and the humor at FARM.FM today suits the mood.
A worked example
A small group of friends holds a Saturday tasting with four honeys from a farmers market: a pale spring honey, an amber summer wildflower, a creamed clover honey and a dark fall honey. They label cups A to D, and one friend keeps the key. They taste in order from lightest to darkest, but with creamed honey tasted with the amber one since both are mid-range.
Notes: A is delicate and floral with a short, clean finish. B is fruitier, with a hint of citrus and a longer finish. C is smooth, mild and sweet, with a creamy texture. D is dark, with hints of molasses and spice, and a slightly bitter finish. When they reveal the labels, two friends are surprised that their favorite was the cheapest jar. Another discovers she prefers the dark honey for cooking even though she liked A best on its own. They each record a favorite use and decide to buy from two of the producers.
Common mistakes
- Tasting too many honeys.
- Starting with the strongest honey.
- Skipping the palate cleanser.
- Judging a crystallized honey as flawed.
- Comparing honeys of very different temperatures.
- Treating one tasting as the final verdict, since honeys vary by harvest.
Safety
Honey is not for infants under 12 months; see the CDC botulism page. People with diabetes should ask a clinician about honey intake; see local honey for people with diabetes. Use clean spoons and avoid double-dipping if sharing.
Frequently asked questions
How many honeys should I compare at once?
Three to six is a good range. More becomes tiring and the differences blur.
Should I taste blind?
It is useful if you want to avoid bias from price or labels, but not required. Many people enjoy tasting with labels and stories.
Does color predict flavor?
Roughly. Light honeys tend to be milder and dark honeys bolder, but there are exceptions. Taste to know.
Can I compare honey in tea?
It is better to taste plain first, since tea and heat change flavor. Try a second round in tea if you plan to use it that way.