Lobster: New England Traps and Buying Tips
Understand how New England lobster is trapped and managed, what hard-shell and soft-shell mean, and how to buy, store, cook and eat live lobster with confidence.
Few seafoods carry as much regional pride as the Atlantic lobster. From the rocky coast of Maine through the rest of New England and beyond, lobstermen set traps from small boats, haul them by hand or hydraulic winch and sort the catch on deck. The result ends up in shacks, markets, restaurants and kitchens, steamed whole, picked into rolls or tucked into bisques and pastas.
Buying lobster is easier once you understand a few basics: how the fishery works, what the terms on the tank mean and how to cook it. This guide covers the essentials without pretending to cover every local custom or regulation.
How the fishery works
Lobsters are caught in baited traps, also called pots, set on the seafloor and marked with buoys that carry a license holder's colors. Fishermen check traps regularly, measure each lobster and return those that are too small or too large, and in many places those carrying eggs. Lobster fishing is closely regulated, with rules on trap limits, gear, size limits and licensing that differ by state and area. The fishery is often described as managed under scientific assessment, with concerns about warming waters and the effects of changing ocean conditions. The NOAA Fisheries and FishWatch sites provide current information, and Seafood Watch offers a consumer-friendly rating.
Many lobstermen belong to small family businesses tied to specific harbors. See local fishing communities and working waterfronts.
Hard-shell and soft-shell
Lobsters molt, shedding their shell to grow. Right after molting, the new shell is soft, and over weeks it hardens. This produces two market categories.
| Type | Characteristics | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Hard-shell | Fully hardened shell, firm, full of meat | Shipping, travel, steaming at home |
| Soft-shell or shedder | Thinner shell, more water, sweeter meat | Eating locally soon after catch |
Soft-shell lobsters are common in late summer and fall in some regions and often cost less per pound, but they have less meat for their weight and travel poorly. Hard-shell lobsters are meatier and sturdier. Ask your seller which you are buying, and choose based on how soon you will cook.
Sizes and terms
Lobsters are sold by weight, with common market names such as chicks (about a pound), quarters (a bit more), halves, selects and jumbos. Many sellers also offer culls, which are missing a claw, usually at a lower price. A one-pound lobster yields a modest amount of meat, so many diners plan on one to one and a half pounds of live lobster per person, depending on appetite and sides. Size names vary slightly by region and seller, so check the actual weight.
How to buy live lobster
- Pick a lively one. A healthy lobster waves its claws and curls its tail when lifted. Avoid sluggish or limp lobsters.
- Check the tank. It should be clean and cold, with no heavy smell or many dead lobsters.
- Feel the shell. Hard shells feel firm, and soft-shell ones give when squeezed.
- Look for claws and antennae. Missing claws mean a cull, and intact antennae suggest good handling.
- Buy from a reliable seller. See how to find local fish markets and docks and buying fish direct from fishermen.
Dead lobsters spoil rapidly and should not be bought or cooked unless known to have died only moments before. When buying cooked lobster, ask when it was cooked, and keep it cold.
Transporting and storing
Bring a cooler. Keep lobsters cool and damp, wrapped in wet newspaper or seaweed, not submerged in fresh water, which kills them, and not on direct ice. Store them in the refrigerator, covered with a damp cloth, and cook them the same day if possible, or at most within a day. Keep bands on the claws until cooking. See ice, coolers and transport for general advice.
Cooking
Two common methods are boiling and steaming.
- Steaming: Put an inch or two of salted water in a large pot and bring to a boil. Add lobsters, cover and steam, usually about 8 to 10 minutes per pound for the first pound and a few minutes for each additional pound, until the shell is bright red and the meat is opaque. Times vary by pot and size.
- Boiling: Use a large pot of heavily salted water, add lobsters head first and cook for about the same time, then lift out.
Cook lobster meat to 145 F or until firm and opaque. Cool briefly, crack the claws and tail, and serve with melted butter and lemon. Many cooks also grill or broil split lobster. Some people prefer to chill a lobster briefly before cooking, though views on humane methods vary. Whatever method you choose, work quickly and carefully.
Overcooked lobster turns rubbery, so watch the time. Leftover meat keeps for a couple of days in the refrigerator, in a covered container, and works well in rolls, salads and pasta. See seafood safety.
Eating a whole lobster
Twist off the claws, crack them with crackers or a mallet and pull out the meat. Twist the tail from the body, push the meat out from the fan end and remove the dark vein. The tomalley, the green digestive organ, is eaten by some, but can concentrate contaminants and toxins in some conditions, and agencies sometimes advise against it, so follow local advisories. Legs hold a little meat for those willing to suck it out. Shellfish are a major allergen, and shells should be kept away from guests with allergies.
Price and seasonality
Prices follow supply and demand. Landings are generally highest in summer and fall, and prices can drop when supply rises and climb in winter and holidays. Shedders can be cheaper but meatier hard-shell lobsters give more for the money. Frozen tails and processed meat provide year-round options; see buying frozen local seafood. For broader timing, see seasonal seafood: what is fresh when.
A worked example: a lobster dinner for four
A family drives to a harbor lobster pound and picks four one-and-a-quarter pound hard-shell lobsters. They ask the seller to band the claws and pack the lobsters in damp paper in a cooler. At home, they steam them in a big pot with an inch of salted water for about 12 minutes, until the shells are bright red, and let them rest briefly. They serve them with butter, corn on the cob and potatoes, and put out a bowl for shells. Later, they pick leftover meat and chill it, then use it for lobster rolls the next day. They compost the shells or boil them for stock, and the whole meal takes under an hour.
Fishermen say the best tool for lobster is patience and a good pair of gloves, and FARM.FM ranching reckons cattle work the same way.
Frequently asked questions
Is hard-shell or soft-shell lobster better?
It depends. Hard-shell lobsters have more meat and travel well, while soft-shell lobsters are sweeter, cheaper and best eaten close to where they are caught.
How long can I keep a live lobster?
Ideally cook it the day you buy it, and no more than a day or so, kept cold and damp. Do not store lobsters in fresh water.
Why do lobsters turn red when cooked?
Heat breaks down proteins that hold the pigment astaxanthin in a different color. The red shows the lobster is cooked.
Is it safe to eat the tomalley?
Some people eat it, but it can concentrate contaminants and toxins. Follow local health advisories, and avoid it if advised, or if you are in a higher-risk group.