Local Potatoes and Sweet Potatoes: Varieties and Storage
New potatoes, waxy types and starchy bakers behave differently in the pan, and sweet potatoes need curing and warmth, so matching variety to dish and storing correctly pays off.
For salads and roasting whole, choose waxy potatoes, which hold their shape. For mashing, baking and fries, choose starchy potatoes, which turn fluffy. All-purpose potatoes sit between the two. Local growers often sell several varieties, so ask which is best for your dish. Store potatoes cool, dark and dry, and sweet potatoes in a warmer, dry spot, and neither belongs in the refrigerator for long.
Potatoes and sweet potatoes are not close relatives. Potatoes are tubers from a plant in the nightshade family, while sweet potatoes are storage roots from a plant related to morning glories. Both are valuable local crops that keep well, which makes them staples of fall and winter eating.
New potatoes and storage potatoes
New potatoes are harvested young, often in early summer, before skins fully set. They are small, thin-skinned, moist and sweet, and they do not store long. Eat them within days. Storage potatoes are harvested mature, cured and kept for months. Local farmers markets often offer both over the season, so buy new potatoes for quick meals and storage potatoes for stocking up.
Waxy, starchy and all-purpose
| Type | Texture | Best uses | Examples of general kinds |
|---|---|---|---|
| Waxy | Firm, moist, hold shape | Salads, roasting, boiling | Red potatoes, fingerlings, many yellow types |
| Starchy | Dry, fluffy | Baking, mashing, fries | Russet types |
| All-purpose | In between | Many uses | Many yellow and white types |
Varieties vary, so ask the grower. Many local farms grow heirloom varieties in colors like purple, red and yellow, with different flavors and textures. For the heirloom story see heirloom vegetables and why growers keep them.
Choosing potatoes
- Look for firm potatoes with smooth, dry skin.
- Avoid green patches, which indicate solanine, a bitter compound that can cause illness in large amounts.
- Avoid sprouting, soft spots, wrinkles and mold.
- Do not buy potatoes with a sour or moldy smell.
- Small bruises can be cut away, but heavy damage means skip.
Green skin and sprouts are signs of light exposure or age. Cut away small green areas generously and discard heavily green or bitter potatoes. This is a reasonable precaution for all potatoes, especially for children.
Choosing sweet potatoes
Choose firm, heavy sweet potatoes with smooth skin and no soft spots or mold. Sweet potatoes are often cured after harvest, a warm and humid period that heals scrapes and converts starches to sugars. Local sweet potatoes usually appear in fall, and many tastes improve after a few weeks of storage. Varieties include orange, white, purple and yellow types, with different textures. Orange types tend to be moister and sweeter, and white or yellow types are drier and more starchy.
Do not confuse sweet potatoes with yams. In the US, many orange sweet potatoes are sold as yams, but true yams are a different plant, rarely seen in regular markets.
Storage
Potatoes keep best in a cool, dark, dry and ventilated place, such as a cellar, basement or cool closet. Light causes greening, and warmth causes sprouting and shriveling. The refrigerator is generally too cold for long storage because cold can convert starch to sugar and give an overly sweet taste and dark color when fried. A cool pantry works for shorter storage. Keep potatoes away from onions, which can speed spoilage.
Sweet potatoes prefer warmer temperatures than potatoes, typically a cool room temperature, and they do not like the refrigerator. Keep them dry and ventilated. Use any with soft spots immediately.
See root cellaring and cold storage and how to store local produce so it lasts for broader storage advice.
Cooking basics
- Boil waxy potatoes starting in cold salted water for even cooking.
- Roast at high heat with oil, cut into even pieces.
- Mash starchy potatoes, warming the butter and milk first for creamier results.
- Bake russet-type potatoes pricked and rubbed with oil for crisp skin.
- Roast sweet potatoes whole or cubed until caramelized.
- Fry cut potatoes dry for better crisping.
Leftover cooked potatoes should be refrigerated promptly and eaten within a few days. Foil-wrapped baked potatoes left at room temperature for long periods can create conditions for harmful bacteria, so refrigerate promptly and follow general food safety guidance from the CDC.
Preserving potatoes
Freezing raw potatoes does not work well, but blanched and cooked forms, such as mashed potatoes or hash browns, can be frozen following tested instructions. Home canning potatoes requires a pressure canner and a current tested recipe, since potatoes are a low-acid vegetable and carry a botulism risk. The National Center for Home Food Preservation provides tested methods. Do not use a water bath for potatoes. See pressure canning when you need it.
A worked example: buying for the month
A household buys a twenty-pound sack of storage potatoes and ten pounds of sweet potatoes from a farm in October. They store the potatoes in a cool, dark basement in a ventilated box and the sweet potatoes in a dry closet. They use new-crop potatoes early, since freshly dug potatoes are more delicate. In November they roast waxy potatoes for dinner, mash starchy potatoes for guests, and bake sweet potatoes for a casserole. In December, they check the stash, remove one softening potato and note that sprouts are starting on a few. They use those first. By January the supply has nearly run out, and the household saved money compared with weekly grocery buying.
Growing and buying seed potatoes
Do not plant grocery potatoes if you want a disease-free crop. Seed potatoes from a reputable source reduce the risk of spreading disease. A Master Gardener program can advise on varieties and planting times. See Master Gardener programs.
Why buy local
Local potatoes often come in more varieties and have fresher flavor, particularly new potatoes. Buying a bulk sack in fall is often cheaper per pound. Farmers love to talk potatoes, and humor is plentiful at FARM.FM rural life about the farm family whose cellar contains more potatoes than the town can eat. FARM.FM food has ideas for using them.
Frequently asked questions
Are green potatoes dangerous?
Green skin signals higher levels of a bitter compound. Cut away small green areas and discard heavily green potatoes, especially if they taste bitter.
Should I wash potatoes before storing?
No. Store them unwashed and dry, and wash just before cooking.
Can I eat sprouted potatoes?
Small sprouts can be removed if the potato is firm, but discard soft, shriveled or heavily sprouted potatoes.
Are sweet potatoes healthier than potatoes?
Both are nutritious in different ways. Preparation matters more than the label, so enjoy both as part of a varied diet.