Imperfect Produce: Buying Seconds at Farm Stands
Seconds are cosmetically flawed but edible fruits and vegetables sold at a discount, and knowing which flaws matter helps you save money and cut waste.
Seconds are the fruits and vegetables that do not make the cut for the display table. They may be cracked, scarred, misshapen, oversized, slightly soft or too ripe to travel, but they are usually perfectly good to eat. Farm stands and market growers often sell them at a discount, sometimes in a separate box or bin, sometimes only if you ask.
For a shopper, seconds are one of the best deals in local food. They suit canning, sauce, soup, baking, freezing and anything that will be cut up, cooked or blended. For a farmer, they turn a loss into a sale. The trick is knowing which flaws are cosmetic, which signal real spoilage, and what to do with the fruit once you get it home before it turns.
What counts as a second
There is no legal grade you will see at most stands. The term is informal. Typical seconds include:
- Tomatoes with cracked shoulders or catfacing, the puckered scars on the blossom end.
- Peaches and plums with soft spots, sun scald or small blemishes.
- Cucumbers and zucchini that are curved, oversized or have a pale side.
- Apples with hail marks, russeting or minor bruising.
- Berries that are very ripe, small or slightly crushed.
- Peppers and eggplant with scars or odd shapes.
- Carrots and potatoes that are forked, split or very small or large.
Growers also sell overripe fruit, which is ideal for jam, smoothies and baking. Some of this is called "canners" or "juicers," depending on region.
Flaws that are fine
Cosmetic flaws include cracks that have healed over, surface scars, odd shapes, discoloration from sun, russeting on apples and pears, minor insect marks and small bruises that you can trim off. These generally do not affect flavor, and in some cases fruit that has struggled a bit tastes better.
Flaws to watch for
Not every defect is harmless. Be cautious with:
- Mold, which can spread beyond what you see in soft fruit.
- Fermented or sour smells, particularly in berries and melons.
- Deep, wet, spreading rot.
- Fruit with open cracks that have fermented or have flies.
- Leaking, slimy greens.
- Any produce that has been stored in the sun for hours.
When fruit is very soft, plan to use it the same day. Trim away bruises, and if in doubt, throw it out. The USDA's Food Safety and Inspection Service has general food safety guidance, and our guide to washing and handling farm fresh produce explains safe preparation.
Best uses for each kind
| Second | Best uses | Avoid |
|---|---|---|
| Cracked tomatoes | Sauce, soup, salsa | Long storage |
| Overripe peaches | Jam, cobbler, smoothies | Fresh slicing for display |
| Bruised apples | Applesauce, cider, pie | Lunchbox storage |
| Oversized zucchini | Bread, fritters, stuffed | Salads |
| Soft berries | Jam, sauce, freezing | Holding overnight |
| Forked carrots | Stock, roasting, soup | Raw peeling trays |
How to ask for them
Many growers will not advertise seconds, because they do not want to discount first-quality produce. Ask politely: "Do you have any seconds or canning-grade boxes?" Some will hold a box if you order ahead. Mention what you intend to make, and quantity helps. A farmer who knows you will take twenty pounds of soft tomatoes for sauce can plan for you. Be flexible about timing, because seconds appear when the harvest is heavy or after a storm.
Pay a fair price. Seconds are cheaper, but the grower still invested labor. Our piece on why local produce costs what it does explains why a discount does not mean the grower is getting rich from them.
Using seconds well: speed matters
Soft fruit moves fast. Plan to process within a day or two. Sort the box when you get home: use the ripest first, trim any bad spots, wash and cook. Freeze extras on trays, then bag them. For canning, always follow a current tested recipe, since acidity and processing times matter for safety, and low-acid foods carry a risk of botulism if processed incorrectly. See the National Center for Home Food Preservation, and our beginner guides to buying produce in bulk for canning and freezing and canning tomatoes safely. Never invent your own processing times.
One caution: for canning tomatoes, use sound fruit, not rotten fruit. Overripe or damaged tomatoes can be lower in acidity, which is why tested recipes call for added acid.
A worked example: twenty pounds of tomato seconds
You pick up a box of cracked tomatoes for a fraction of the first-quality price. When you get home, sort them: a few have deep rot and go to the compost, a handful are cracked but firm, and most are soft and ripe. Cut out cracks, cores and bruises. Cook the ripest ones into sauce on the stove that evening, and freeze the sauce in portions. Slice the firm ones for sandwiches. The box that would have cost much more as first-quality now supplies a month of sauce and a week of lunches. If you plan to can any of it, use a tested recipe from a trusted source and follow it exactly. Farm.fm readers will appreciate that the only thing a tomato does faster than ripen is rot, and FARM.FM farming has stories about a cracked crop and the farm wife who turned it into gold.
Other benefits
Buying seconds reduces food waste. A large share of food grown never reaches a plate, and some of that waste starts with cosmetic standards. Local growers who sell seconds, donate extras or work with gleaning groups keep good food in use; see gleaning programs and volunteer harvests.
Seconds can also help you try something new. If you have never made fruit butter, a cheap box of soft pears is an inexpensive experiment; the guide to making fruit butters and sauces has ideas.
Frequently asked questions
Are seconds safe to eat?
Generally yes, if you inspect them, trim damaged areas, wash and cook or eat promptly. Avoid anything moldy, slimy or sour smelling. Soft fruit should be used quickly, and when in doubt, discard it.
Are seconds cheaper everywhere?
Not always. Some farms discount heavily, some only slightly, and some do not sell seconds at all because they use them for their own value-added products. Ask at the stand, and compare to the price of first-quality items.
Can I can or freeze seconds?
Yes, with care. Freezing is simple for berries, peaches and tomatoes. For canning, use fruit that is sound, follow a tested recipe, and do not skip acid or processing steps. Heavily damaged fruit is better used fresh.
Why do farmers sell seconds at all?
It lets them earn something from a crop that would otherwise go to waste, and it gives shoppers an affordable way to buy large quantities. It is a win for both sides when both are honest about quality and price.