Pickling Cucumbers and Other Vegetables
Pickling preserves local vegetables in an acidic brine, and safe results depend on tested vinegar and salt ratios, fresh produce and the right canning or refrigeration method.
Pickling is one of the most flexible ways to preserve local produce. Cucumbers are the classic, but beets, green beans, carrots, peppers, onions, cauliflower, radishes and even fruit can all be pickled. The basic idea is simple: submerge vegetables in an acidic brine, usually vinegar, with salt and seasonings, and either keep them cold or process them in a canner for shelf stability.
Simple does not mean careless. Safety depends on enough acid, which comes from tested ratios of vinegar to water and other ingredients, and on following the correct method. Tested pickle recipes are designed so that the acidity of the finished product is high enough to be safe, and altering them can make the difference between a safe jar and a risky one. A farm-stand pickle jar has been the subject of more family disagreements than the writers at FARM.FM food could ever settle, but the rules for safe pickling are not up for debate.
Three ways to pickle
| Method | How it works | Storage | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Refrigerator or quick pickles | Vegetables in hot or cold brine, kept cold | Weeks in the refrigerator | |
| Canned pickles | Tested recipe processed in a boiling water canner | Shelf-stable when sealed | |
| Fermented pickles | Salt brine encourages natural fermentation | See [[a:fermenting-vegetables-sauerkraut-and-kimchi | fermenting vegetables]] |
Quick pickles are the easiest beginner approach, and since they are never shelf-stable, they must be refrigerated. Canned pickles must follow a tested recipe and a water bath process; see water bath canning for beginners.
Choose the right cucumbers
Use fresh, firm pickling cucumbers, ideally the same day they are picked or bought. Pickling varieties are shorter, with thin skins and bumpy surfaces, and stay crisp better than slicing cucumbers. Look for no soft spots, mold or yellowing. Cut off the blossom end, which contains enzymes that can soften pickles, and wash well. Ask growers at the market which varieties they recommend; see farmers market basics. Seasonal fruit and vegetables may differ from region to region and with weather.
Brine basics
- Vinegar: use commercial vinegar of the strength a tested recipe specifies, typically labeled 5 percent acidity. Do not dilute beyond what the recipe allows.
- Salt: use canning or pickling salt, free of anti-caking agents that can cloud the brine.
- Water: use filtered or soft water if your tap is very hard.
- Sugar and spices: may be adjusted slightly to taste in many recipes, but not the vinegar-to-water ratio.
- Dill, garlic, mustard seed, peppercorns and other seasonings are traditional.
Never reduce the vinegar or increase the water in a tested canning recipe. If you like milder pickles, use sugar or a refrigerator recipe designed for it.
Steps for canned pickles
- Choose a tested recipe from the National Center for Home Food Preservation or your extension service.
- Wash cucumbers and trim the blossom end.
- Prepare jars, lids and brine as the recipe directs.
- Pack vegetables and spices into hot jars, leaving the stated headspace.
- Pour hot brine over them, remove air bubbles, wipe rims and apply lids.
- Process in a boiling water canner for the recipe's time, adjusted for altitude.
- Cool, check seals, label and store. Wait several weeks for flavor to develop.
Keeping pickles crisp
- Use the freshest cucumbers possible and keep them cold until processing.
- Trim the blossom end.
- Do not overprocess, as extra heat softens vegetables.
- Some tested recipes use a brief soak in cold water or ice; follow the recipe.
- Avoid unsafe additives, and use only crisping methods from tested sources.
Other vegetables to pickle
Beets, carrots, green beans, cauliflower, onions, peppers and radishes all pickle well, but each has its own tested recipe. Do not use cucumber instructions for other vegetables, because density and acidity differ. Low-acid vegetables are safe in pickles only because of the vinegar in the brine, and the proportion of vegetables to brine matters. Salsa and relishes are tested separately. Allergen note: label mustard and other seasonings if you share.
Safety checks
Discard any jar that is bulging, leaking, spurting, cloudy in a way not explained by spices, or smells off. Do not taste doubtful food. Refrigerator pickles must stay cold and be used within the time the recipe states. Fermented pickles can develop surface yeast, and spoiled ferments should be discarded. If you ever suspect botulism symptoms such as double vision or trouble swallowing after eating home-canned food, seek emergency care; see the CDC botulism pages. Never invent processing times or brine ratios.
A worked example: dill pickles
You buy a peck of fresh pickling cucumbers from a nearby farm on the morning you plan to can. You choose a tested dill pickle recipe, wash and trim the cucumbers, and measure vinegar, water and salt exactly. You pack cucumbers with garlic and dill into hot jars, pour over hot brine, wipe rims, apply lids and process for the listed time for your altitude. After cooling you check seals, label and store. You wait a few weeks before tasting the first jar, which is crisp and tangy. A smaller test batch of refrigerator pickles went straight into the fridge for the week's barbecue.
Related reading
For general principles, see home food preservation 101. If you buy in bulk, buying produce in bulk for canning and freezing has tips, and eXtension offers tested guidance.
Flavor, spices and serving
Once the safe base is settled, flavor is where pickling gets fun. Dill, garlic, mustard seed, coriander, peppercorns and bay leaf are classics, and a pinch of red pepper adds heat. Bread and butter styles use more sugar, while sour dills use none. Within a tested recipe, you can usually vary the seasonings, as long as you do not change the amounts of vinegar, water, salt or vegetables. If you are unsure what a recipe allows, check its notes or ask your extension office.
Let canned pickles rest for several weeks so the brine can penetrate and flavors can mellow. Serve them with sandwiches, chop them into potato salad and tartar sauce, or tuck a few slices into a cheese board. Brine from a finished jar can be reused for a quick refrigerator batch of fresh vegetables, though only for cold storage, never for canning again. Label jars by type and date, and keep a note of which batch was your favorite so you can repeat it next year.
Frequently asked questions
Can I reduce the vinegar to make milder pickles?
Not in a canned recipe. The vinegar ratio provides the acidity needed for safety. Use a refrigerator recipe designed for milder flavor or add sugar if the tested recipe allows.
Why did my pickles go soft?
Common causes are old cucumbers, leaving the blossom end on, overprocessing or weak brine. Use fresh produce and follow the tested recipe.
Do I need special salt?
Canning or pickling salt is best because it dissolves clearly and has no additives that cloud the brine. Check your recipe for alternatives.
How long do refrigerator pickles last?
Usually several weeks if kept cold, but follow the recipe. They are not shelf-stable.